Analyzing Malala Yousafzai’s Speech to the United Nations

The stage is set. Now it’s time to meet Malala Yousafzai. My students were already somewhat familiar with her, because her book graces my whiteboard marker holder. However, they really didn’t know her full story—except for the students who were curious enough to read the book. And since her speech to the United Nations mentions how the Taliban attempted to murder her and that she’s passionate about education, I thought it would only make sense to introduce the students to her through short video clips.

I found a good one published by The New York Times titled “The Malala Yousafzai Story: The Pakistani Girl Shot in Taliban Attack”. It introduces the viewer to Malala’s family and their experience with living in a community in Pakistan that was transformed by the Taliban. It is less than 20 minutes long. Then I supplemented it with a video, only about 5 minutes, titled “Malala Yousafzai, 16, and Her Miraculous Story of Surviving Being Shot by the Taliban”.

Malala had a dream to become a doctor. She attended the school her father owned. Even after the Taliban forbid families from sending their girls to school, Malala and others risked their lives to get an education anyway. One day she was riding the bus with her classmates. At a checkpoint, the shooter opened the bus door and asked for Malala. After she identified herself, the shots fired. She was shot right through the side of her forehead.

Human Rights: An Introduction

As I noted in my previous post, my students will explore human rights issues through various readings, choose a topic, research it, develop a thesis and an outline, write an essay, revise, edit, rewrite and publish it. In addition to the formal paper, each student will present his claim through the medium of his choice.

Today my students were introduced to the concept of human rights. However, since we had been away on break, I reminded them that we are going to write an argument, which is a little different from the expository pieces we had been writing throughout the semester, and really, since the fourth grade.

I introduced the class to the following words: exposition and argumentation. Yes, they sound like big words, but I assured them that they have been exposed to both of these types of writing without even knowing it–through reading books and writing exercises assigned by teachers.

My Virtual Scribble Pad

…Human rights make up the backdrop for this unit. Each student will eventually have to develop a thesis that falls under this category. Their thesis will be the basis for their argument. The hope is that as they read the various texts, they will discover the authors’ theses and identify how they support their claims. With exposure to different models of argument and some exploration of a topic that interests them the most, I want each student to develop her own claim. Hopefully the students will see the importance of reading as a way to prepare for writing–especially an argument. Another way to look at this is that writing an argument just means that we are joining a conversation that is already in progress.

…Students will read excerpts from thinkers such as Abraham Lincoln, Thomas Paine, Mary Wollstonecraft, Sojourner Truth, Malala, Gandhi, Pope Francis, and Martin Luther King, Jr.; poets, such as Elma Stuckey, and other authors including W.E.B. Du Bois, George Orwell, Harper Lee, Anne Frank, Alex Haley, and Aldous Huxley will also be explored. The students will not only identify their claims, but they will look for the evidence that these influential people have used to support them. In addition, they will evaluate and assess the evidence. This is particularly important for 8th graders to begin doing before they start high school.

*Note: According to the Common Core Standards for English Language Arts, this is the biggest difference between the 7th and 8th grade expectations for writing an argument. Seventh graders must use relevant evidence while 8th graders must use well-chosen, relevant evidence. Eighth graders will evaluate and assess the evidence of other writers and begin to strategically select evidence to include in their writing.